Question: My wife and I have no sexual relations, which I find frustrating. Masturbating has become the norm. I feel that divorce may be necessary, because I am missing the closeness of a relationship. I am Jewish and she is not.
What do you advise?
The first commandment we are taught in Torah is to be fruitful and multiply. We are obligated by Jewish Law to marry and have children, one boy and one girl to be exact. We are also told that “spilling seed” (masturbation) is not permitted because the sperm wasted could have produced a child. There is such a high value placed on life and having children that there are Jewish Laws that state that one may divorce one’s wife if she is barren.
Intimacy is very important. Divorce, while difficult, is a far better option than cheating on your wife or living with resentment. It is always better to openly deal with marital issues, in your case, sexual relations with your wife or lack thereof. There are therapists who are experts in this arena and this specific type of marriage counseling.
That being said, living in a loveless marriage, whether related to sexual relations, communication issues or a myriad of other discords that drive partners apart, it is not healthy for either party to stay in such a relationship.
In Reform Judaism being Jewish or not is not the issue. If you choose the path of divorce after honest reflection with your partner, you will have to go through civil law practices of your state to be legally divorced. Then gittin (Jewish Ritual Divorce) is by choice, but something I do recommend. I recommend it because one never knows who they will fall in love with and if the new person is more observant not having gone through gittin would be an issue down the line.
This is a difficult situation. I hope this helps in figuring out what your next step will be.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: There seems to be a tension between the Jewish mitzvah (commandment) concerning marriage (and subsequently being fruitful), and the concept of love (specifically romantic love, as defined in terms of western thought and literature). In times and places where arranged marriages are/were the norm, this was not a concern, but in modern day America, it seems to be a live issue. Is it the view of Judaism that it is more important to marry to fulfill the commandment - even if one does not love that mate, or should one not marry without love even though the mitzvah seems clear that it is obligatory? What does Judaism say, not only halachically (in Jewish law), but ethically and in terms of Jewish values?
As a Reform Rabbi, I believe it is important to know the mitzvot (commandments) and then make an educated choice as to which mitzvot one chooses to observe/follow. Be fruitful and multiply, the first commandment is extended by the halacha to only be fulfilled if one has a boy and a girl. Binging children into a loveless marriage is not good for anyone.
Middot (Jewish Values) are also important to know and understand. Shalom Bayit meaning peace in the home would apply to marriage. Kavod (Dignity and Respect), another middot, is also important to the success of a marriage. Without these two values, no matter how obligatory, it would not be healthy to marry and have children. True, people may grow to love one another, and for some, arranged marriage is still the norm, but, what happens if the relationship does not evolve into love or there is not mutual respect? It is difficult on a relationship if one marries for materialistic items or reasons; ideally a successful marriage is based on the partners having similar values, beliefs, and unconditional love.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: Just wondering if there is a simple and appropriate prayer for friendship. I teach preschool and I was hoping to find a prayer of thanks to others for their friendship.
Music is a wonderful way to reach children. There is a very sweet song by Doug Cotler called Thank You God. It is on his “It’s So Amazing” CD. If you go to his website, you can listen to it, I believe. I have used this song with young children & at consecration. The verse that is perfect for what you are describing is, “Thank you for my friends & thank you for my toys. Thank you God for watching over all the girls & boys…Baruch ata Adonai, Thank you God”
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: Do women have the same obligation as men in regards to daily prayer in Judaism?
Women do not have the same obligation for daily prayer as men. According to Halacha (Jewish Law), women are not obligated to observe positive, time-bound mitzvot (commandments). Because men are commanded to pray 3 times a day at specific times (you shall...morning, afternoon, & evening) women are exempt. However, there is nothing that says they are not able to pray if they desire to do so.
Depending on the congregation, women may or may not be counted in a minyan (the group of ten Jews needed for communal worship). In most liberal congregations women do count in a minyan; they do not in an Orthodox community. The reason women are not obligated to positive, time-bound mitzvot is traditionally they were the ones who cared for the home & had the responsibility of teaching and raising their children making it difficult to be bound to specific obligations at specific times each day.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: What is the Jewish perspective on stem cell research?
Reform Movement passes a resolution on Stem Cell Research in 2003. I share with you what was presented and approved in 2003. This is the most precise view of the Union For Reform Judaism. This has supported actions taken and comments made by the Religious Action Center for Reform Judaism in statements made on issues that are voted on in our government.
67th General Assembly
November 2003
Minneapolis, Minnesota
RESOLUTION ON STEM CELL RESEARCH
BACKGROUND
Jewish tradition teaches us that preserving life and promoting health are among the most precious of values. These values have informed our affirmative commitment to medical science throughout the ages. Judaism has always encouraged scientific and medical advances. As Nachmanides taught, the practice of healing is not merely a profession, it is a mitzvah, a righteous obligation. A recent CCAR responsum applies this principle to human stem cell research: "If we define the administration of lifesaving medical therapy as pikuach nefesh, we should not forget that physicians could not save lives were it not for the extensive scientific research upon which our contemporary practice of medicine is based. Since research into human stem cells partakes of the mitzvah, of healing, surely our society ought to support it" (CCAR Responsum 5761.7, Human Stem Cell Research, Rabbi Mark Washofsky).
Continuing developments in biological science have opened the door to life-enhancing and life-saving technologies. The sequencing and mapping of the human genome, in particular, have profound implications for medical technologies. At the forefront of these possibilities is the opportunity for treating or preventing diseases through gene manipulation, often called "gene therapy." Somatic gene therapy attempts to correct a genetic defect in the cells or tissues of an individual in order to prevent or treat disease and may help heal or prevent debilitating afflictions. Somatic gene therapy should not be confused with germline therapy, which is more controversial and involves changes to an individual's genetic makeup that can then be passed on to future generations, with unknown implications and potential complications.
Stem cell research involves cells that can potentially develop into any kind of cell, tissue, or organ in the body ("totipotent stem cells") and that may one day soon be able to replace damaged or sick cells in a patient with an injury or degenerative disease. For example, scientific research into stem cell regeneration holds the promise of finding new and effective treatments for Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, spinal cord injuries, and certain types of cancers. The moral imperative to pursue stem cell research is clear; it is an embodiment of the mitzvah, of healing. Our tradition requires that we use all available knowledge to heal the ill, and "when one delays in doing so, it is as if he has shed blood" (Shulchan Aruch,Yorei De`ah 336:1).
Totipotent stem cells are commonly obtained by using somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) technology. This technique, commonly referred to as cloning, involves the removal of the nucleus of an unfertilized, mature egg and its replacement with a genetically complete nucleus obtained from another adult or fetal organism. Since almost all of the hereditary genetic material of a cellis contained within its nucleus, the entity into which this egg develops is genetically identical to the organism that was the source of the transferred nucleus.
While some argue that stem cells harvested from adults and the existing stem cell lines are sufficient for research, most in the scientific community maintain that the use of SCNT technology to develop new stem cell lines ("embryonic stem cells") is critical to further development of the medical research. It is important to note that there are ample sources of embryos for research that are currently being discarded and that research using embryonic tissue would not require the creation of new embryos for the purpose of such research.
"Therapeutic cloning" uses SCNT technology to create cells that develop only until the pre-embryo stage, at which point the stem cells are removed. These stem cells are then used to research possible cures for serious medical diseases and conditions. In contrast, "reproductive cloning" attempts to use this technology to produce a living, breathing human being. This resolution deals with therapeutic cloning; it does not address the issue of reproductive cloning of humans.
SCNT technology can play a vital role in exploring the causes and treatment of genetic diseases; it may help to develop therapies for the afflictions mentioned above, and it may also help develop stem cells to regenerate human tissues, nerve cells, and skin cells.
Some opponents of SCNT technology argue that every fertilized egg could be allowed to develop into a fetus. Halting the process to harvest the stem cells seems to them like killing a fetus-a perspective the URJ has never accepted. Numerous URJ, CCAR and WRJ resolutions and CCAR Responsa about when life begins clarify our views in this area. (See, for example, the 1985 and 2000 CCAR Responsa related to abortion, found on-line at www.ccarnet.org/resp.)
To other opponents, the possibility for abuse of SCNT technology seems overwhelming, and for this reason, they would prohibit the entire field of research and therapy. While we recognize the potential abuses that could arise from SCNT technology, these concerns can be met by taking measured, cautious steps and are far outweighed by the potential benefit of medical procedures that promise to cure so many. JEWISH TRADITION TEACHES THE VALUE OF SAVING EVEN A SINGLE LIFE, AND THE CALLOUSNESS OF FAILING TO SAVE A LIFE WHEN POSSIBLE. AS WE LEARN IN THE TALMUD, "WHOEVER CAUSES THE LOSS OF A SINGLE SOUL IS AS THOUGH HE CAUSED THE LOSS OF A WORLD ENTIRE; AND WHOEVER SAVES A SINGLE LIFE IS AS THOUGH HE SAVED A UNIVERSE" (TALMUD, SANHEDRIN 37a).
Clearly, there is a need for moral and ethical deliberation, yet we know that millions of God's children are plagued by diseases and injuries that we have the potential to heal. The ethical choice must be to advance our research into lifesaving technologies, not abandon it.
THEREFORE, the Union for Reform Judaism resolves to:
Support:
Research using both adult and embryonic stem cells, in addition to the existing lines currently approved for funding by the United States and Canadian governments;
Research using somatic gene therapy;
Research using somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) technology for therapeutic cloning; and
Government funding for all such research;
Oppose efforts to restrict or penalize scientists, clinicians, or patients for participating in stem cell research and SCNT technology for therapeutic purposes;
Support appropriate legislative and executive actions consistent with the above objectives;
Support efforts by the scientific community to develop regulations and monitor those using SCNT technology; and
Call upon congregations, in conjunction with the URJ Department of Jewish Family Concerns and the Commission on Social Action, to create educational programs that explore the issues raised by genetic technology within a framework of Jewish values.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: Why don't some Ultra-Orthodox Jews celebrate Yom Haatzmaut? If they have a reason, wouldn't it also apply to other parts of the Jewish world?
I begin with a disclaimer: the following response is a generalization and, as with every group, there are those who do not fit the generalization. That being said, many Ultra-Orthodox Jews (Haredim) believe that the modern State of Israel was established prematurely without God's blessing. Because of this, while many live in Israel, they abstain as much as possible from matters of the state. For this group of Jews, Israel can only come into existence when the Messiah has come and the Temple in Jerusalem is rebuilt.
In 2009 Eliezer Hayon of www.ynetnew.com wrote a controversial article with the headline, “Why Haredim Don’t Honor Memorial Day.” He wrote, “Ultra-Orthodox don’t participate in national Memorial, Independence Day [Yom Ha’atzmaut] not out of spite, but because these days mean nothing to them.” Hayon writes, “Memorial Day and Independence Day are not part of their historical chronology.” He adds, “The haredi street does not celebrate Independence Day not because haredim think – like the eccentric minority that calls itself Neturei Karta – that this is a sad day, but because Independence Day, which for many is a national day and a highly important historical date, is for them a day like any other.”
In the United States the celebration of Israel Independence Day is often a time when Jewish organizations and synagogues of different denominations, from liberal Jews to the Modern-Orthodox, cooperate in forming a common celebration. It is a way to express solidarity with the state of Israel; and, like in Israel, the Ultra-Orthodox often self select not to participate and view the day as any other.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: I have several regular charities I give to, but this year I am unable to keep up my level of giving due to salary cuts. Is it better for me to cut out a few charities, or to reduce or minimize my level of giving to all of them?
Our text teaches the importance of giving and our obligation to give as Jews. Every amount is helpful and does make a difference. As with a coat of mail, each piece contributes to make a whole. Each part is important for the protection of the person wearing the armor.
In the current economical situation many find themselves in your same situation. Salary cuts are common as are lay-offs of all people. This is not an issue of class, profession, ethnicity, religion, race…it is a product of our economy. Non-profits, secular and Jewish, are finding it necessary to cut their budgets. In light of this, the Talmud teaches many valuable lessons about how much one should give including an upper limit, “One who wishes to donate [generously] should not give more than a fifth of his income, lest he himself come to be in need of charity.” Babylonian Talmud, Ketubot 50a. Levels of giving are a private matter. My recommendation is to give what you are able and not feel badly. Look at your giving patterns and reduce as needed in proportion to your current salary.
As the economy improves, you will once again be able to raise your level of giving. Our rabbis teach that life is like a revolving wheel. People who never imagined they would be faced with decisions such as the one you share; or may be in need of financial assistance themselves are questioning how they can give to others and maintain their own well being. We must realize that perception is reality. It is difficult to know from the outside what one’s financial situation is like. In the end, we never know when we will be in need of taking charity when once we were the ones who gave.
People don’t often ask the question you posed. Many find it difficult to admit their financial troubles. Today, many are living on significantly less than they are accustomed and giving less as well. Despite this, “even a poor man who himself survives on charity should give charity.” Babylonian Talmud, Gittin 7b.
Giving financial resources are important. Giving of time is also an option. With budget cuts, more charities are dependent on volunteers to help where once there may have been paid staff. You might also be able to donate in-kind contributions base on what you do for a living. When your wheel again turns then you will be able to return to level of giving for which you were once capable. Now it is important to remember all are created B’tzelem Elohim, in God’s image and all people are worthy of Kavod, honor and respect. You honor both yourself and others giving as you are able.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: What options does traditional Judaism provide to solve the Agunah (chained woman) problem? Why are these not more broadly applied? Is there a chance to solve this issue once and for all?
There are many organizations today based in Orthodox Judaism regarding a solution for the issue of Agunah.While there is no clause added to the ketubah as is present in the Conservative Movement (the Lieberman Clause allowing for women to initiate divorce; Orthodox women and rabbis have taken action in favor of women’s rights.Many orthodox rabbis encourage grooms to sign prenuptial agreements before they sign the ketubah.This is a very serious issue because Jewish women without a get (Jewish divorce document) are trapped and may not marry again if not granted such a document; even, with a civil divorce.Some organizations even make it possible to serve the man with a get (Jewish divorce document) if he refuses to come before a beit din.They will also attempt to locate the man if the woman does not know ever where he is.Awareness is key and strides are being made.
In the Reform movement it is left to the rabbi’s discretion to suggest whether regular burial services and mourning rites would benefit the family in the case of a still-born or a baby which dies within 30 days.I would not question whether or not to have a funeral.I would suggest that the family choose a simple burial, with close family and friends (perhaps some of the medical professionals who supported the family through such a tragedy). A funeral and tradition mourning rituals provide an opportunity for the family to grieve.
If they would like to have a shiva minyan, fine.If they want the baby’s name read during the period of sheloshim, fine.My responsibility as a rabbi (family and friends) is to comfort the family and reassure them that the many emotions they are experiencing are valid.If they do not want something done formally, this is their choice and I would never force the issue.Perhaps, it may be more than they are ready to grasp at the moment.In this case, I would talk with the parents of the child and determine what might be done to help begin the healing process.
The death of a child, no matter what the age, is heart retching.Healing will come; however, memory will not die.It is also important to not pass judgment on the decision the parents make.This is not a time to be critical.It is not the time to hold fast to tradition or to quote text.
Traditionally, there is not a service (your understanding is correct).According to Jewish law and traditional beliefs, mourning rites were not observed for infants who died within 30 days after birth for they were considered abortive (J. Yev. 11:7; Shab. 135b)” Then, little was made of infant deaths or abortions. They occurred frequently and the communities would have been in a constant state of mourning if rites had been required.
In any case, he/she is buried, and not disposed of like a miscarried or aborted fetus. A miscarriage may, however, be disposed of by the hospital or clinic in accordance with its usual procedures. According to Reform Jewish Responsa literature, "No burial is necessary but it is also not prohibited; we would suggest it for infants and possibly for still-births."So, while this is a decision ultimately of the parents, others should be supportive and the rabbi should listen and really hear the emotions, concerns, thoughts, pain and fears.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: November 9, 2010, is the anniversary of Krystallnacht. How should we be continuing to remember the Holocaust today?
November 9, 2010, is the anniversary of Kristallnacht. How should we be continuing to remember the Holocaust today?
Oral History, personal stories and/or collective stories linked to artifacts, pictures, and diaries.If you are able, make the journey to Germany, Poland, and other counties that were occupied by the Germans. In addition, remember that there were many countries where survivors were able to escape: China; England (Kinder transport), Australia, (there are many if one does the research).Also remember that each story is unique and to never say, “I have already heard a survivor speak.”
There are many ways to teach the Holocaust with the method above honoring the memory of those that perished and those survivors who are no longer present. Most every community I have lived in or traveled to, large or small, has someone who is connected to the Holocaust – directly, through family, WWII veterans who fought on the western front (many survivors or, some prefer the word refugee, are also WWII vets who were able to pretend they did not know the language; and, were able to share information they heard or translated.Also, you can connect with the Jewish War Veterans group in your community or nationally.Sadly, many of these people are no longer living, are child survivors that may or may not be able to tell their story.
Personal stories may be based on collective history, video, diaries, publications by survivors, their children, or grandchildren.These connections are what touch the heart of others and make what is historical for so many – real and tangible.As a grandchild of survivors, I find it more meaning full to honor the survivors and their descendants during times like Yom HaShoah, Kristallnact, Yom Kippur, (for those more observant) T’shabav, and on other significant dates.
An example, as a grandchild of survivors, what I have done for these observance is not have a speaker who does an academic overview or monuments of today, the most “famous in town” survivor who speaks or a guest who travels and tells their story, but, I like to call all the members of a survivor’s family up to light a tea candle from another larger candle.It is very powerful to see how many have had children that they never thought was possible.Many have even been blessed to see the 4th generation.
Imagine 20+ people, 4 generations and including not only survivors but those in the community who are 2nd generation who are not living in the same city or whose parent is deceased.I share brief bios beginning with what their journey was to America, how the couple met, how long they have lived in the community, where they first settled and from where, what they did when they arrived here…you get the idea.
This communicates what is rare to hear in the 21st century “Look at my arm.How can you say this did not happen?” Or “hear me, listen to me” I tell my grandparents story sharing the telegram that I inherited when my grandpa died.It was sent to my grandma’s mother and sister in Canada.I said that said she and her brother were alive.I have photos of those who perished because of the two that went to Canada in 1938.I have group family photos and I was not afraid to ask questions.I also have a letter that my grandma wrote to me for a school project about her experience.
If this is not a part of your personal history – reach out to a survivor who may not have someone to remember their story or have an interested family member.Learn it and share it.If they have items or photos, preserve them and share them with others.I have spoken at conferences representing the 3rd generation, secular and Jewish school, governmental agencies with diversity sessions, and I have a 17 minute film of grandchildren of Holocaust survivors that grew from my rabbinic thesis which included original research of this generation.
If someone doubts or questions the legitimacy of what you shared, know the history behind what you are sharing.What happened when people were in hiding, what happened in the work and death camps, how people escaped to freedom.With the German and Russian achieves open, it is possible to do research, finding documents that are detailed are incredible resources.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: What if someone is experiencing problems at work, such as a hostile work enviroment. Perhaps the employer would rather give an employee a bad time, hoping they'll quit, as opposed to firing them (to avoid paying out unemployment benefits). How does one handle that situation? In this day and age, quiting a job might not be a good thing to do, because the next job might not be just around the corner.
Quitting a job takes strength and courage, especially in the current financial environment; however, as one who has been hit very hard by the economy and one who has also been in the situation you describe first of being given a hard time so that the company is not responsible for paying unemployment. The second was my first job out of undergrad in advertising. I was so intimidated, financially could not quit, but dreaded each day.
Not only does a negative work environment and abusive or harassing professional relationships affect our confidence and self-esteem; but, our health is also compromised. Once I was told, for example, that a rabbi has to take the bruises, so to speak. Each of us is created B’tzelem Elohim, in God’s image and each of us are deserving of kavod, dignity and honor.
In Judaism Pekuach Nefesh, saving a life is important. It is so significant to our faith that one may even break the laws of Shabbas to fulfill Pekuach Nefesh. Also, we are taught in Torah to choose between life and death, the blessing and the curse, choose life. This to me means that we are able to choose how we live. Will we live an enlivened life or will be feel dead inside - often because of the stress or extra weight we carry in our life.
In the past 3 years I have learned not to be angry with God, saying, “Why are You doing this to me,” but rather, “What is the purpose.” And though I don’t always know; I do know that difficult times are often times to evaluate our priorities and to realize that money is important; however, it is not the source of happiness. In my setting priorities I have come to realize what I preach (If only I would listen to my words) self care is critical, followed by good health, caring for others (family, friends, pets…), and then having a life choice that brings satisfaction (also financial security and health insurance).
Often in difficult work environments or in situations where we feel that nothing is good enough, that we have to put up with what we are experiencing because the other choice of not finding a job right away is frightening, especially if we are the primary earner. However, please remember, when we say a MiSheberach for healing it is not only for body, but also mental healing and healing of the soul. Physical health is certainly compromised by the situation you describe above.
Being a grandchild of survivors, I draw strength from knowing they came to this country financially and mentally destitute and many were able to begin again, carve out opportunities for themselves and their families (accepting jobs even if they did not know the trade), and make a living. Most were able to renew their belief in God and others.
There are many stories where people have to start over, and/or reevaluate their lives. In this economy there are many in careers one would never imagine to be so impacted financially. There will be good days and bad; but, self care is very important for us to be able to care for others and take the steps, perhaps hesitantly, for a renewal of spirit and self.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: In the past few decades, there have been more concerns about over-population and the risks it brings to the environment and people. When I raised such a concern to a friend (also Jewish) of mine, he accused me of not trusting in G-d. My concern is that having too many children reduces the standard of living for everyone and ruins the gifts G-d has given us. Where is the balance between "be fruitful and multiply" and protecting our world as well as the people in it? Does adoption fulfill the mitzvah of multiplying?
As a parent who is blessed to have adopted a son, I have helped to “save a life” so to speak. He was not born of my womb, but in my heart. This is significant regarding your concern about over-population and environmental risks. The best way to honor the world and God is to practice the mitzvah of saving a life – a mitzvah that takes precedence over observing Shabbat and all other mitzvot. I will never know what the quality of my son’s life might have been had he stayed with his birth mom and/or dad; however, I do know that his birth mom felt as if she were a holy vessel carrying our baby during the time of her pregnancy.
As the Talmud states, “The one who brings up a child is called parent, not the one who merely begot the child. (Sh’maot Rabbah 46)” I am absolutely convinced of this. Perhaps, Jewish law or other Jews may not agree, but as a mother, adoption absolutely does fulfill the mitzvah “be fruitful and multiply”. Why? Because you are giving life, so to speak, to a person who may have never known someone to call mom or dad.
When a baby, toddler, young person, teen, (domestic or international) is given the love and security of a parent or parent(s), this is multiplying – happiness, the way others are treated, dignity, respect. Those who adopt make a conscious choice. The process is often difficult for others to understand: the hoops, the waiting, the fear, the agencies, the travel, the understanding of others that maternity (or paternity) leave really is necessary (the bonus - we don’t have to worry our co-workers about missing work for morning sickness or bed rest), lack of medical history, waiting for finalization or authority to travel, timing, and though I hate this - the costs.
You are not adding another soul to this earth (again the concern of over-population), but you are raising a child whose soul will be enriched and enlivened, because of the way you have chosen to become "fruitful and multiply". Jewish tradition teaches, “Whoever raises an orphaned boy or girl in his house, Scriptures considers as though actually bearing the child. (Megillah 13a)” Be fruitful and multiply, not from the womb – but from the heart which is also a link to the mind, a conscious choice. Referring back to the first text - you are the parent.
A parent is given the blessing of a child who can make a difference in this world – no matter if born of the womb or heart – and with your guidance and values, may bring healing to the pain, suffering, poverty, and darkness. You become a role model, teacher, and you are his/her parent; the one who helps to shed light on the issues of the world and and hope to others. You are able to partner with God – what better demonstration of belief is there? You have acted B'zelem Elohim, in God's image, by breathing life into this child. He/she is a gift from God. Many of my friends and colleagues of all faiths, my congregants who have come to me when considering adoption or when they are in the waiting stage will tell you there is no better gift. There are also Reform Jewish Respona which address this very issue.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: What is the Jewish view on obligation to care for aging parents?
The Torah teaches us, “Honor your father and mother.” There are many ways for us to do this as our parent’s age and many choices of how we can do this depending on the circumstance of care they need.
Rabbi Joshua ben Levi said, “Honor and respect the aged and saintly scholar whose physical powers are broken, equally with the young and vigorous one; for the broken tablets of stone, no less than the whole ones, had a place in the Ark of the Covenant. Many have obligations toward aging parents and children, some even grandchildren. As people age and are living longer, Jewish tradition can teach what our obligations are.
Hillel teaches…If I cannot adequately care for myself, I am obligated to allow another trusted person to assist me…but I must be aware of his or her personal needs and feelings also. And, I may not wait until the last minute to accept or enlist the help I need.
Maimonides instructs…One should select as attendants and caretakers those who can cheer up the patient [resident]. This is a must with every illness.
Remember, though it may be difficult to have these conversations with our parents; it is always more meaningful when we work in partnership with aging parents. Knowing the wishes of our loved ones and knowing their desires when they are in good health is so much better than reacting in a crisis situation which causes undue stress to all involved. Often, however, it takes a crisis to open our eyes. And often, decisions of what to do, unfortunately, (especially in today’s economy, 2010) come down to fiduciary issues.
Rabbis of the Palestinian Talmud and Babylonian Talmud teach the following and of course are in debate. On the one hand, Palestinian Rabbis say, “Children must support their impoverished parents even if the children themselves are poverty stricken (JT Kiddushin, 1:7).” One the other hand, Babylonian Rabbis say, “The money for such support should come from the estate of funds of the parents (BT Kiddushin 32a).” So who do we follow today? Both: The family is not required to impoverish themselves in the pursuit of fulfilling the commandments and parents have a responsibility to handle as much of their own financial obligations of care giving as possible.
Why is money such a hot issue? Money makes independence possible, independence fosters self-worth, and self-worth makes life meaningful. This is the last way in which a parent can be a self-directing and self-supporting person. Remember a parent who is old is still an adult. What life has taken away in terms of capabilities does not mean total incapacity until that state is truly reached.
Today, Rabbi Dayle A. Friedman teaches, “Judaism offers a perspective on relationships between adult children and their parent that can provide us with compassionate, pragmatic moral guidance. Our tradition urges respectful attentive care, on the one hand, and on the other hand, recognizes and supports accepting the limits of what adult children can do.” It is fully appropriate under Jewish law to turn to in-home nursing services, a part-time arrangement, or a nursing home placement. Finding assistance, which allows the child to work, can be a mode of personal service, of demonstrating honor and respect.
- Rabbi Holly Cohn
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Question: What should a Jewish person do if his or her loved one (also Jewish) wants to be cremated after they die?
First, join a Reform congregation. Actually, as an ordained rabbi from Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion, I have done many funerals for members and unaffiliated Jews who have been cremated. (I have also done funerals for those who have chosen to donate their body to science - another issue for Jew to ponder).
I base my response on two things, honoring the wishes of the person who is pre-planning (always the best way to go), who is dying or has died and what I know from the Reform Rabbi's Manuel.
The current Rabbi’s Manual, published in 1988, states: “We continue to stress that burial is the time-honored Jewish way of disposing of the dead... However, the practice of cremation has lately spread, for a number of reasons. We would reiterate that it ought to be discouraged if possible, especially in our generation which has seen the murderous dispatch of millions of our people by way of crematoria. If, however, cremation has been decided upon by the family, we should not refuse to officiate. It is suggested in such cases that the service be held at an appropriate place and not at a crematorium.”
My grandparents are Holocaust Survivors, yet this is not the image I picture when one choose to be cremated. I picture the person as they were in life and feel for the many emotions present when a loved one has died.
Click here to view all of the answers for this question.
Copyright 2020 all rights reserved. Jewish Values Online
N O T I C E
THE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN ANSWERS PROVIDED HEREIN ARE THOSE OF THE INDIVIDUAL JVO PANEL MEMBERS, AND DO NOT
NECESSARILY REFLECT OR REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF THE ORTHODOX, CONSERVATIVE OR REFORM MOVEMENTS, RESPECTIVELY.